Skip to content

How to do Secret Santa without anyone knowing (even the organiser)

The four steps, the draw problems everyone hits (your own name, couples, the organiser who knows everything) and how it works with odd numbers, tiny groups and people spread across the country.

By AmbarStudios · · 4 min read

Secret Santa sounds like the simplest game in the world: everyone draws a name and buys that person a present. Then you try to organise one. Somebody draws themselves, a couple draws each other, half the group can't make the draw and the person holding the hat now knows who has whom. This guide covers how to do Secret Santa properly, including the questions people actually get stuck on: odd numbers, tiny groups and keeping it secret from the organiser.

How to do Secret Santa in four steps

  1. Ask who's in. Send one message with the budget, the exchange date and a deadline to reply.
  2. Agree the budget. £10 is the classic at work; £15 to £25 is common among friends and family. A narrow range works better than a single number.
  3. Draw the names. Everyone gets one name, nobody gets their own, and ideally only they know who it is.
  4. Exchange. At the Christmas do, a dinner or on Christmas Day, with gifts labelled only with the recipient's name.

Steps one, two and four are easy. Almost every problem comes from step three.

Drawing names without anyone knowing

The hat method has three classic failures. If the last person is left with their own name, everyone has to draw again. Couples and housemates who'd rather not draw each other are left to luck. And if someone can't be there, the organiser draws for them and immediately knows their match.

There are two ways round it. The low-tech fix is to draw one at a time in private: each person goes into another room, picks a slip and puts it back if it's their own. It stops the peeking, but the last person can still be stuck with their own name, and everyone has to be there on the night.

The easier fix is drawing online. In Secret Santa App & Wish Lists the organiser types in first names, marks anyone who shouldn't draw each other and sends a private link to each person in the group chat. Each link shows only that person's match, the budget and the date, so the organiser can join in like everyone else. There are no email addresses to collect, and the others don't need to install anything.

Odd numbers and small groups

A common worry is that Secret Santa needs an even number of people. It doesn't. Nobody is paired up to swap with one person: the draw makes a loop where Amy buys for Ben, Ben for Cara and so on until it comes back round. That works with any number from three upwards.

Group sizeDoes it work?What to watch
2Not reallyYou both know who has whom; just swap presents
3YesEveryone can work out who has them; fine for fun, not for mystery
4YesWith two couples excluded from each other, each person must draw from the other couple
5 to 7Yes, very wellSmall enough that everyone knows everyone
8 or moreYesUse wish lists, since people know their match less well

For a group of three who still want a surprise, try a twist: everyone buys a small gift for both other people, with half the budget each.

Doing Secret Santa online or by post

When the group is scattered, between flats in different cities, family in Scotland and Cornwall or colleagues working from home, the draw is the easy part online. The posting is what needs planning:

For the workplace version, including hybrid teams, see Secret Santa for work.

The reveal

You don't have to reveal at all; some groups keep it secret for ever. If you do, make it a game: each person opens their gift, reads the tag and has one guess at who their Santa was. Only then does the Santa own up. It takes ten minutes and is usually the best part of the evening.

Frequently asked questions

How do you do Secret Santa if the organiser is taking part?

Use a draw where the organiser never sees the full list. With private links, the organiser learns one name, their own match, exactly like everyone else.

What if someone draws their partner?

With a hat, you start again. With exclusions set before the draw, it simply can't happen.

What if someone drops out after the draw?

If nobody has shopped yet, remove them and give the person who drew them a new name. Everyone else's match stays the same.

More guides

All blog articles